
You were driving home on the I-405 when another driver drifted across the lane line and slammed into your car. Weeks later, the medical bills keep arriving, you have missed work, and the other driver’s insurance company has offered its full policy limit. That limit covers only part of what the crash has cost you.
In California, you may be able to make up some of the difference through underinsured motorist (UIM) coverage on your own auto policy. Whether it applies, and how much it may pay, depends on your limits, what the other insurer pays, and the steps you take before you settle. If you were hurt in a car accident caused by a driver with low limits, knowing these rules early can help protect coverage you already pay for.
How Underinsured Motorist Coverage Works in California
UIM coverage is governed by California Insurance Code § 11580.2. Insurers must include this coverage unless a named insured deletes or reduces it in writing. A vehicle is underinsured when its liability limits are lower than the UIM limits on the injured person’s own policy.
- Written waiver: Coverage is included unless a named insured rejected or reduced it in writing
- Limits comparison: The at-fault driver’s limits must be lower than your own UIM limits
- Exhaustion: The other driver’s liability coverage generally must be paid out first
If the other driver had no insurance at all, the rules on how uninsured motorist coverage benefits you apply instead.
Common Situations Where the At-Fault Driver’s Coverage Falls Short
The table below summarizes the situations in which UIM coverage most often comes into play in California.
| Scenario | What Usually Happens | Where UIM May Help |
|---|---|---|
| Driver carries only state minimums | Other insurer pays up to its per-person limit | May cover losses above that limit |
| Serious freeway crash injuries | Bills and lost wages exceed the policy | May add coverage up to your own limits |
| Several people hurt in one crash | Injured people share the per-accident limit | May help when each share is small |
| Hit as a pedestrian, cyclist, or passenger | You may still qualify under your own policy | Depends on who your policy defines as insured |
A Driver Carrying Only the State Minimum
California’s minimum liability limits are set by California Vehicle Code § 16056. For policies issued or renewed on or after January 1, 2025, the minimum is $30,000 for injury to one person and $60,000 for all people in one accident. Surgery or months of therapy can exceed those amounts, and higher UIM limits on your own policy may cover part of the difference.
A Serious Crash on the I-405 or I-710
Crashes at freeway speed often cause fractures, spinal injuries, and head trauma that require long recoveries. Even limits above the state minimum may fall short, and months away from work can widen the gap quickly.
Several Injured People Sharing One Policy
When a crash injures several people, everyone may draw from the same per-accident limit. Each share may be small, so understand how the policy is divided before you accept payment.
Hurt as a Pedestrian, Cyclist, or Passenger
Depending on how your policy defines an insured, UIM coverage may apply if you were hit while crossing Pacific Coast Highway, riding a bike, or riding in a friend’s car. For a broader overview, see this guide to uninsured motorist coverage in California.
The Offset Rule: How Your UIM Payment Is Calculated
UIM coverage is not simply added on top of the other insurer’s payment. Under Insurance Code § 11580.2, the most your UIM insurer generally owes is your UIM limit, reduced by amounts paid by or for the person responsible for the injury. This reduction is often called the offset. Because of it, UIM coverage tends to help most when your own limits are well above the other driver’s.
Before UIM benefits apply, the statute generally requires that the bodily injury limits of every policy covering the vehicles that caused your injury be exhausted by settlement or judgment, so accepting less than a full limit may cause problems. Suppose your UIM limit is three times the at-fault driver’s limit, and that insurer pays in full. The most your UIM insurer would generally owe is the remaining two-thirds of your limit, and your actual recovery still depends on proving your damages.
Where Compensation May Come From After a Low-Limits Crash
More than one source of payment may be available, and each one can affect the offset.
| Source | When It May Apply | What to Check |
|---|---|---|
| At-fault driver’s insurer | The driver caused the crash | Policy limits and any other policies |
| Driver’s employer | The driver was working at the time | Commercial auto coverage |
| Umbrella or excess insurer | The driver or owner carries extra coverage | Whether the umbrella covers that vehicle |
| Your UIM insurer | Other limits are lower than yours | Declarations page and policy terms |
The at-fault driver may also be personally responsible for losses beyond the insurance, although collecting from an individual is often difficult.
What You Must Show and What to Do Next
What You Must Prove
- Show the other driver was at fault. Your UIM claim generally depends on the underinsured driver being legally responsible.
- Confirm the vehicle was underinsured. The other driver’s limits must be lower than your UIM limits.
- Prove the other policy was exhausted. Your insurer may require proof that those limits were paid.
- Document losses above that payment. UIM benefits apply only to damages beyond what was credited.
Steps to Take Now
- Get the at-fault driver’s policy limits. Knowing them early shows whether a UIM claim may be needed.
- Review your declarations page. Confirm your UIM limits and whether anyone signed a waiver.
- Notify your insurer in writing. Check your policy for notice or consent terms before you accept any settlement.
- Keep every bill and pay stub. These records support the value of your claim.
UIM Deadlines, Arbitration, and Comparative Fault in California
A lawsuit against the at-fault driver is generally subject to the two-year deadline in California Code of Civil Procedure § 335.1. Your policy and § 11580.2 may add their own timing rules for UIM claims. If a government vehicle was involved, a claim against that agency may need to be filed within six months under California’s Government Claims Act.
Under § 11580.2, disputes with your insurer over whether you can recover, or how much, are generally decided by agreement or arbitration rather than a jury. California also follows pure comparative fault under Li v. Yellow Cab Co., so your recovery may be reduced by your own share of fault rather than barred.
Compensation a California UIM Claim May Cover
UIM coverage applies to bodily injury, up to your limit after the offset. It may include:
- Medical expenses: Emergency care, surgery, therapy, and future treatment related to the crash
- Lost income: Wages and earning capacity lost because of your injuries
- Pain and suffering: Physical pain, emotional distress, and loss of enjoyment of life
How a California Personal Injury Attorney Helps With UIM Claims
A UIM claim means negotiating with your own insurer, which may value your injuries differently than you do. An experienced personal injury attorney can help with:
- Policy review: Identifying every liability, umbrella, and UIM policy that may apply
- Exhaustion and notice: Coordinating the other insurer’s payment with your insurer’s requirements
- Damages proof: Gathering medical records, bills, and wage documents
- Arbitration: Presenting evidence and testimony if your insurer disputes the claim
Frequently Asked Questions About Underinsured Motorist Claims
Q: Is underinsured motorist coverage required in California?
Insurers must include it unless a named insured deletes or reduces it in writing. Your declarations page will show whether you have it and in what amount.
Q: What if the other driver’s limits are higher than my UIM limits?
If the at-fault driver’s limits equal or exceed your UIM limits, the vehicle generally does not qualify as underinsured. Your recovery would then come from the other driver’s policy and any other responsible parties.
Q: Do I have to go to court for a UIM claim?
Usually not. UIM disputes are generally resolved by agreement with your insurer or through arbitration.
Q: What should I do if the other insurer offers its policy limit?
Before you accept, check your policy for notice or consent terms and notify your own insurer in writing. The timing and paperwork can affect your UIM rights.
Contact a California Car Accident Attorney Today
When the at-fault driver’s insurance runs out, you may face medical bills and lost income with nowhere obvious to turn. UIM coverage may help close that gap, but only if the limits, notice terms, and offset rules are handled correctly.
The Law Office of Michael D. Waks helps injured people in Long Beach, Los Angeles County, and throughout Southern California pursue the compensation the law allows after crashes with underinsured drivers. We handle injury cases on a contingency fee basis, which means you pay attorney fees only if a monetary recovery is obtained. Contact us for a free consultation.
- What If the At-Fault Driver’s Policy Limits Are Too Low? - November 18, 2026
- Who Is Liable for Injuries on Private Property in California? - August 27, 2026
- What Are Signs of Nerve Damage After Dog Bites in SoCal? - August 26, 2026